Other Kitty (and how she came to be with us)
I’ve been putting off writing this post for the longest time. I think because I don’t know how to put words to what turned out to be an extremely emotional and spiritual experience for me, and if I’m going to be really honest I’ve been putting it off because I know I won’t be able to write it without crying. And then you all will think I’m crazy. The crazy cat lady. Well sit back and have a drink, because this is going to rival one of David’s blog posts in length.
Let’s start at the beginning. We live downtown and I first saw her one day in May when she ran down our driveway, past my office windows and across the street. She caught my attention because she looked just like our cat Pegasus. And come to think of it, our neighbor mentioned seeing a Pegasus look-alike skulking around the neighborhood. A few days later I saw her run by again. In that moment, a powerful, invisible force compelled me to fly out of my chair to the refrigerator, grab the lunch meat, and run out the front door. I spotted her in the alley across the street. She stopped thirty feet from me and we had a stare down.
I could see she was a stray, a scraggly bag of bones with large mattes in her fur. She was very afraid. Gently squatting down, I tossed bits of lunch meat to her, tossing each piece nearer to me until she was inching closer and closer. She ate it ravenously. My heart broke into a million pieces. I was suddenly devastated for this hungry, lonely creature. I’ve always loved animals and have an intense desire to rescue them from suffering. The sight of the Barnum & Bailey circus in town right now makes me want to stand outside and implore the children, “DON’T LET YOUR MOMMY TAKE YOU IN THERE!” Oh how I hate the kind of existence this provides for animals, but don’t get me started on that.
But back to my story, I held my breath as she crept within hands reach to get the food. Then she did the unthinkable. She rubbed her head against my hand as if to say thank you. Something about that moment took my breath away….knowing how afraid she was, but how desperate she was for help. I gave her more meat and sat in consternation deciding what to do. I didn’t want her to get away for fear I’d never catch her again. So in my haste, I attempted to pick her up in the idea that I would carry her home. Worst idea EVER! (Note to self, don’t be a freaking amateur and pick up feral animals!). She yowled and hissed and clawed me from head to toe to get away from me. And then she ran. She looked back at me in fear and she ran away as fast as her little legs would carry her.
I trudged home heartbroken, feeling like a complete failure. (I know, I’m so dramatic). But I couldn’t help feeling like I had earned her fragile trust and then proceeded to scare the crap out of her for life. It seemed like I’d never get the chance to help her now because she’d never come near a human again! So what did I do next? I put my head in my hands and started sobbing. I called David crying, and he probably thought I’d lost my marbles, crying about lunch meat and some stray cat that I had utterly betrayed and now everything was lost! I couldn’t explain why I was so upset, because I didn’t understand it myself. Something in me had just connected with a needy, hurting animal and I felt like I had blown it. I didn’t know what else to do so I begged God to please provide another chance and please, please, PLEASE let me help her somehow!
That night I laid in bed and listened to the sound of the pouring rain drumming on the roof. I wondered where she was. How she was staying dry. If she was hungry. I couldn’t sleep.
The next day I put a food and water dish outside the house. Later I walked by and spotted her out the window eating the food. Each day she came back, but if she ever saw me she took off running. The thing that struck me most was how sad it was that she lived in such fear. Constant fear of every loud noise, every neighborhood dog, every storm, every person. I wanted to show her how to be happy and find her a home. So David helped me construct an ingenious Looney Tunes trap. With a stick, we propped open the swinging porch door that led outside. We tied a long string to the stick that led through the porch and under the door into the house. Then we put the food in the porch hoping that she would sneak in to eat it, and seeing her through the glass door I could yank the string which would pull the stick out of the back door and trap her.
After a couple days she worked up the courage to venture in to get the food. I pulled the string, but she was so quick that she shot out the door before it closed. The second time she came I yanked the string and the door slammed ON her as she bolted out. Then I really felt like a jerk. She didn’t come back for a few days after that. Longingly I looked out the window hoping beyond hope to see her there. But she didn’t come. My heart sank lower each day. And weighing heavily on my heart was the fact that we were moving out of our house. The movers were coming the next morning, and my chance to help her would be forever gone. There were only a few hours left in the day, and I was so sad and that I couldn’t take it anymore. With resignation, I took out the stick, brought in the food and let Pegasus go out on the porch to bird watch. I dismally prayed, “Lord, please take care of that cat and watch over her. Send her help. I tried my best but now there’s nothing I can do.”
Feeling empty and depressed, I went back to editing in my office. About 5 minutes later I heard meowing. High pitched, sweet little meows filled with longing. It didn’t sound like Pegasus, so I got out of my chair and walked to the porch.
And there she was.
Sitting on the other side of the screen, trying with all of her might to communicate her intentions of friendship with our 15lb fluffy black kitty. Hurriedly, I set the trap up again. This time I did a trail of cheese all the way inside. I squatted down and waited, and soon enough she crept in to eat the cheese. I yanked the string and the door slammed shut. My heart was pounding. I was shaking from head to foot. I had trapped her. And on the last possible day.
The story of rehabilitating her is as long (or longer) than the story of trapping her. It involved teaching her to be pet, trimming the painful mattes out of her fur, taking her to the humane society, but bawling my head off that she might be euthanized, calling david again crying, bringing her right back home. She came with us to the new house and lived in the mudroom until we had her screened for disease. We thought she was possibly a kitten since she’s so small, but after examination he estimated she was 6-7 years old. I even paid to have her spayed in hopes it would make her more adoptable. After her surgery the vet called to tell me that her uterus was full of cysts, and if she had stayed on the street she would have died of cancer. (Apparently the Wenzel’s are a cancer fighting machine!) I tried to find her a home on Craig’s list, but that fell through. David didn’t really think we should keep her. I didn’t know what to do. We weren’t looking to have another cat, but I knew she was a part of my story. I knew what I had gone through to rescue her.
So in the meantime, she was the other kitty living in the mudroom. Throughout the day I would go sit on the floor and talk to her. She would purr and nervously try to sit on my lap. Then one day she crawled all the way into my arms and buried her face in the crook of my arm. Hiding. Purring. I realized this might be the first time in her life that she had ever experienced relationship. The first time she ever had a feeling of safety. The first time she knew what it meant to trust. And I had given that to her. The tears rolled down my face. She laid in my arms, and I cried and cried. I thought, “Isn’t that what we all want? A hiding place. Someone to trust. A place where nothing bad can happen to us because we are completely safe from harm?” I’m telling you! This cat is some kind of metaphor for my life!!
Through David’s diagnosis with cancer, other kitty worked her way out of the mudroom and into our home. Pegasus showed her how to be a normal cat. Following his example she started running to the kitchen for treats, vying for affection, and in time she even learned how to play with cat toys (a huge milestone for her considering her life previously consisted of pure survival). She’s come such a long way from the wild cat she once was. She runs to the door to see me home, she approaches strangers, she lets me touch her paws and belly and kiss her (she used to swipe at me for this). The only thing that gives away her identity as a street cat is that still hides under the furniture when it rains because she thinks she’s going to get wet. We’re working on that.
I love Other Kitty because she’s a redemption story. Because she was just a stray cat on the street who no one cared about and no one loved, but I saw her and I loved her. Some might say she had no worth, but she had endless worth to me. Even though she ran from me, I had compassion on her and I went out of my way to pursue her until I could bring her to safety.
And the reason I cry whenever I think about this story is because in my secret heart I understand that this is what Jesus did for me. And it helps me understand how He might feel about me. And I just don’t know what to do with that kind of love.


Comments
So precious Amy! Other kitty looks just like my kitty Casper. Thanks for giving her the home she deserves…you made her life complete.
Just rest in it and let it envelop you. (p.s. neat story)
That kind of love that you have with Jesus? You’re doing exactly what you should be doing with it - passing it on.
And, just as an aside, I think animal people are the best kind of people!
Love and prayers to you and your family (including the kitties!),
Samantha
This story really touched my heart. You have a way with words. I am a huge animal lover! Especially kitties. This same kind of thing has happened to me twice in my life. I know exactly how you felt when you tried to pick her up and she ran away. I am so glad though that she now has a good home. Such pretty eyes she has! Thanks for sharing!
An incredible story of being lost and redeemed by someone through love. Thanks for sharing it. Totally awesome name by the way
Miss Amy, I wish I was still there at the workshop to tell you in person how much I love this story, and how much I love you for telling it. There’s a song I love that says, “Lord, break my heart for what breaks Yours.” Um, I NEVER pray for that because I’m a chicken, but sometimes, in MY secret heart, I wonder what the world would look like if we let ourselves slow down long enough to really feel the kind of compassion you felt for other kitty. I walked past the circus animals today and felt that pang, but I shook my head and forgot it as quick as I could. Sorry I’m such a wuss. Jesus, break my heart for what breaks yours, even though that means I’ll have a broken heart.
Crying as I read this beautiful story. Amy, you are amazing!
What a special story! Well done to Pegasus too!
Amy, this is incredible.
Amy, I have never commented before but have continually read about your struggles. This post is beautifully written and had me sobbing by the end. Your outlook on life is amazing and truly inspiring. Thank you.
Amen, Amy! What beautiful words…and a revelation brought on by a kitty. I knew where your story was headed from the beginning, and I think it is amazing that you witnessed first hand some feeling of love that is so indescribable.
Love it. Thanks for sharing.
Okay you have me in tears… the whole way through this story I was totally thinking about God… and it has turned into a sermon illustration. No joke. Im a youth pastor, and If it’s okay with you, I’d LOVE to use this in a sermon. I think its incredible! And I dont even like cats!
Hi Amy,
I have known of you and your work for about a year now. You photographed a friend of a friend…she thought I would love your work and she was right. Then I was on Chronicles from Windy Ridge and saw a link to you and what was going on with your family. My heart broke for you and I immediately felt the need to follow your story and your amazing journey of hope and faith. Thank you for sharing your stories. You have no idea how strong you truly are. I think that your Kitty is just as big a gift to you as you were for her. You are in our thoughts and prayers.
April
What a wonderful story Amy! Reminds me of a similar story I have of rescuing a baby mouse off of a lily pad in a pond. If you’re a crazy cat lady, then I’m super nuts :). However, I do not have a pet mouse. God used my story for my life much like he’s using yours. I’m so glad you shared.
Beautiful story, Amy!! Thanks for sharing!! PS…Other Kitty looks just like my kitty, Arwen!!!
Wow, what a story…it practically made me cry:) It is awesome that Jesus loves us no matter how much we run from Him or shoo Him away…love your pics and your posts! You and David are in my prayers:)
I just tried to capture a wild stray cat from the grocery store the other day, and it even went in the lunch box after the lunch meat, but I couldn’t seem to catch it…only lost its trust. I know exactly how you felt. This is a truly beautiful story of redemption.
the last paragraph to this post touched me the most. i often feel that exactly! thank you for this! God Bless!
Thank you so much for sharing this. It did make me cry!
And…now I’m crying…
Oh Amy, I am crying. And not just the cute little girl cry, the ugly cry. You know, the one where you can hardly breath, let alone talk. The one where your face is all scrunched up and red, and just down right ugly. This is such a beautiful story, unlike my tear stained face right now.
Thank you for sharing.
First off I want to say, your blogs are so great to read. Often bringing tears to my own eyes! I particularly liked this story because I have 2 cats as well. My first came into my work, and my other came about when the first one ran away for about 10 days and we went looking for her at the Humane Society! They are truly part of my family and their personalities are so cute! I remember calling my husband from work and begging him to let me have this little kitty that strolled into work that day (having it already in my car).
Good times. Thanks Amy 
Wow you don’t know me but every once in awhile I’ll read your blog, and it is so heartwarming and so real!! I love it, I’m serious when I say that you should become a writer!! Serious I feel so drawn in by everything you write!
Other Kitty is Beautiful! What a fabulous story, you are a beautiful kind and caring person Amy!
Wow! What a incredible live-giving story!
Thanks for sharing.
*sobbing in ontario*
He loves us more than we could ever understand, realize or know.
thank you for sharing this story, it means so much and I needed to read that more than you could have ever known.
bless you guys!
It makes me cry too! God never stops teaching us. This cat is one lucky feline (and she looks beautiful too!)
i’m bawling…… i needed this story…
Beautiful, just beautiful.
you’re not a crazy cat lady!!…i am sitting here crying as i read this because i love animals as much as you do
i know other kitty is uber grateful to you for saving her life
Powerful story. It shines a human light on the greatness of Christ’s love for us. Keep on sharing!
Other Kitty was put into your life by God. You are an amazing strong compassionate woman. I am a huge animal lover too, and will go to ANY extent to stop the suffering. Thank GOD Other Kitty was put here to teach us all the lesson of faith, trust, and survival.
Amy, what an amazingly beautiful story. Tears poured from my eyes more than once while reading your story, and not just because it really is beautiful, but also because it is filled with love, trust, fear, anxiety, desperation, and acceptance. I too have a similar story, (actually quite a few when I dare my mind to think about them all but most of the time I can barely go through the thoughts of all the various animals I HAVE to help, because like you, I end up a bawling mess), it is about the one that sits next to me right now as I write, he is a little guy that entered my life when he was about 7-8, that was back in 1998. Now we estimate that our little old man is about 19 years old! He has had (and given us) his fair share of scares over the years but my little loyal fighter is still right at my side every step I take, and I know the Lord has blessed me beyond words with our little Rusty.
Thanks for sharing your story, your kitty’s are beautiful.
Holy hannah Amy. You have such a huge heart - I am in awe and so humbled by your love.
aww, amy. this is such a perfectly perfect story! she’s a beauty for sure!
Beautiful story…and you are so right! Real moments like that truly give us a glimpse of the love Jesus has for us. Congrats on the new addition to your family…
Beautiful!
beautiful—I’m misty—what a story!
That is such a beautiful story Amy and its brought tears to my eyes. She looks just like my cat too. God never gives up on us, even when we keep running away and messing up. we can always come back to Him knowing He is there for us. And His timing is always perfect-look at how Kitty came to you when time was almost gone. I don’t know you Amy but I love you because I can see Jesus light shine from you-its beautiful. Please don’t stop sharing your life with us.
I am sitting here reading this because my husband said I had to read this because, “Amy is just like you, you will love it!” I started to read it and my battery died so I plugged it in and went for my run and headed out to church. Just got back and made a bowl of cereal and started to read this. I had to put the bowl down as tears rolled down my cheeks. No, you can’t eat with a big knot in your throat. Had to comment. I love how you shared with us how it is with us and Jesus. It is so true. I will be sharing this story with others…I love the heart that He gave you for the hurting, downtrodden, and fearful. I have a kitty story, too. I am a kitty story.
Thank you for sharing that small byt significant story in your life.
<3
I boo hoo’ed through the whole story. Very sweet.
Oh my goodness… I have tears. Not that I didn’t think I wouldn’t when I read this. I have an empathetic heart– especially for animals. I might also be considered a crazy cat person, although, my husband only lets me have one cat… (as of right now;)). Bless you for taking this kitty in… bless you!
This story brought tears to my eyes. What a beautiful story of redemption!
Amy, Grandma and I just read your story about other Kitty and it made us both cry (as usual). Loved the analogy. How beautiful! Love, Mom
Amy, this post left me in tears! I feel as though I felt what you felt, and I NEEDED THAT ENCOURAGING POST TONIGHT. It’s so encouraging to know I can crawl up into His arms, bury my head in His grace, and know that I am loved. Thank you! Hope you (& David too!…missed seeing him at Kristen’s party!) are well!
ahh! love that story. i have an “other kitty” too, but her name is mean kitty. lured her off the streets with lunch meat too. she’s not so mean anymore.
I came across your site through several other photography blogs and i think you are an absolutely amazing woman. I have never cried while looking through blogs but i am currently bawling my eyes out. Your love and passion for the lord, your husband, animals, people, your work, and life is so evident. I’ve strayed from where i once was as a christian and reading your stories of how much you rely on God and how he has helped you through so much has really made an impact on me. Thank you.
What a story! I am sitting at my desk at work trying to look like I have an eyelash in my eye, but in reality I’m fighting back tears. And I’m not even a real animal person!
It’s such an awesome, simple reflection of how God loves us. And don’t we all still hide under furniture when it rains, mistakenly thinking we’ll get wet? I can just see God smiling, trying to coax me out and saying “we’re working on that”.
Thanks for sharing this!
What a wonderful story. I find myself feeding cats I find on the street and trying to catch them but usually with no luck. I hate to see animals hurt or hungry. I give what I can, usually just a few dollars to ASPCA and the Humane Society. And when I go to PetSmart I add on a dollar to help pets. Call me crazy but I think I like animals better than people…
You are me and I am you. I cried my way through your story. I have been there. I still have my Formerly Feral Frankie (also black) and Miss Tessa Tutu. Thanks for a beautiful story.
aunt amy,
you should be a professinol writer!your story about other kitty is so so so so so
so so so so so so so so sweet.i had tears in my eyes.
She is beautiful!!!
I REALLY loved this Other Kitty story!! I am a big animal lover myself and dispise the circus. I cried though the story. At one point I couldn’t read cause my eyes were to blurry.
You and your family are wonderful <3
This is so beautiful and the final paragraph helped me understand a little bit more about myself. I too love animals and the treatment of circus animals and those in similar circumstances makes me angry. I loved this story. Thank you for writing it.
I’m writing this with tears in my eyes as I too rescued a tiny cat and when I read your post, was amazed by the likeness of your cat to mine
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kaymaguire/sets/72157622151804972/
and I understood all those feelings you explained:-) it makes me feel like I’ve encountered a kindred spirit. (I’m also married to a David for four years)
I love your photography and your blog and will look forward to seeing your work and reading your wonderful words in 2010. You seem to be a very kind, talented lady.
Kay
Hi Amy, Your story on other kitty was heart wrenching. I felt all welled-up in my throat. She is beautiful. I love the comparison of your loving pursuit of her, to Jesus’ loving pursuit of us. It is so awesome!! I applaud you. I enjoy your writing’s. I too am a Christian Photographer; wanting to exibit Christ in everything I do. I’m trying to see, how I can reflect Christ in my Photography. I don’t want to be “just another Photographer”. I also enjoyed your writing on gettingsharp picture’s. Thank-you, for taking the time to share with us: your life, faith, photography, etc., God Bless You & looking forward to talking to you soon.
What a wonderful expression of love! I thank the Lord for you on behalf of Other Kitty!